Category: Trekathon

A great episode, which clearly influenced the later development of one of Star Trek’s most enjoyable characters, Q. William Campbell is great as the Squire. He plays the role in a very clever way, which both sustains the suspense of the episode, but also makes the final reveal feel like a revelation, rather than a…

A solid Spock episode, let down by the side plot on the Enterprise. It’s interesting to see the weaker side of Spock, when he finds that his ‘logical’ way of commanding doesn’t work well with humans. It’s a little reminiscent of the complaints I’ve heard some people make about Generation Y – you have to…

I was pretty sure I wasn’t going to like this episode from the introduction. Giant white rabbits don’t really fit with my idea of what Star Trek should be. The episode at least partly redeemed itself, though. The idea (and script by SF stalwart Ted Sturgeon) was a good one, and some of the individual…

Wow. Easily the best episode so far. Probably one of the best Trek episodes I’ve ever seen. Clearly the story has a cold war analogy in it, and it wouldn’t be too far fetched to imagine most of the episode happening in a submarine. But the episode goes beyond these origins, and tells an interesting…

Yikes this is a bad episode. For a start, nothing about this story makes it a Star Trek story. This story could have been in any one of twenty TV series with very little problem. I’m pretty sure this would even work as a Love Boat episode. And then there’s the overacting. I know they’re…

Trek’s first two parter continues. The flashback story is at least a little faster moving than in the first part, but this is still a slow moving episode. When the network complained about it being ‘too cerebral’? They were kinda right. Later Trek showed a much better mix of the philosophical and intellectual themes with…

Star Trek was always a bit of a message show. The moral here? Be green, recycle… As most people who watch Trek know, this is a recycling of the original pilot, which was rejected by the network as being ‘too cerebral’. Most of the first part here is dominated by the set up, and it’s…

This is the episode I think of when I think of original series Star Trek. It’s not the greatest story, or the most entertaining. But it’s the one that I remember seeing first. I suspect the story probably had its origins in trying to keep the budget down – only a couple of guest stars,…

A so-so episode – there isn’t really much suspense or unexpected development. It’s pretty clear who the villain is early in the episode. There’s almost no sexual tension between Kirk and the doctor. And there isn’t anything very interesting done with the reprogramming of Kirk. Still, I did enjoy the part about Captain Kirk falling…

A slow episode, but some good SF, and a really nice use of unusual elements in the children. But there are some strange missteps on the way. The most obvious: why would you make this an exact duplicate of Earth? It serves no plot purpose, other than to try and justify exactly why the culture…